Transfer pricing not attracted in the absence of liability to pay tax: AAR

Applicant: Goodyear Orient Company (Private) Ltd.and anr. on 02^nd May, 2011

A.A.R. Nos. 1006 & 1031 of 2010

Assessment Year:

Relevant Facts:

1. The Applicants are

(i) GTRC, a company incorporated in the US

(ii) GOCPL, a company incorporated in Singapore

(iii) GIL, a company incorporated in India.

The companies manages natural rubber purchasing and other business.

2. Entity (i) owns 75% of the shares in entity (iii) and seeks to transfer it to entity (ii) through a Share Contribution Deed (SCD).

Applicants questions:

1. Whether applicant (i) would be charged capital gains or any other tax?

2. Whether transfer pricing provisions are applicable on applicant (i)?

3. Whether any TDS is required to be deducted by applicant (i)?

4. Whether any tax would arise on GOCPL u/s 56?

Allowing the application of the assessee, the Hon’ble Authority held that:

(i) In the absence of any consideration for transfer, no income may be attributed to the transferee and thus, capital gains tax would not be applicable.

(ii) In the absence of liability to pay tax, Transfer Pricing provisions would not apply.

The decision is available here.